you're reading...
-[Film Reviews]-, American Independent Cinema, English Language Film Industries

‘Scott Pilgrim vs. The World (2010): An Action-Musical Tour de Force

Directed by: Edgar Wright || Produced by: Eric Gitter, Nira Park, Marc Platt, Edgar Wright

Screenplay by: Michael Bacall, Edgar Wright || Starring: Michael Cera, Mary Elizabeth Winstead, Kieran Culkin, Chris Evans, Anna Kendrick, Alison Pill, Brandon Routh, Jason Schwartzman, Brie Larson, Ellen Wong, Aubrey Plaza

Music by: Nigel Godrich || Cinematography: Bill Pope || Edited by: Jonathan Amos, Paul Machliss || Country: United Kingdom, United States || Language: English

Running Time: 112 minutes

The phrase “style over substance” as a derisive term never made sense to me with respect to filmmaking. Given how the art of cinema, or the ability of a narrative or project to become cinematic, is by itself an act of visualizing theme, characters, and conflicts, I never understood how a film could be stylish without being substantive. The style of a given film, like most art media, is largely the point of that film, how well it is able to capture or summarize its narrative, themes, or central idea through camerawork, moving bodies, and editing. One could argue particular stylized (re: audio-visual) elements of a film work against its main premise, thus contradicting other elements of its cinematic tone (e.g. pointless digital FX, on-the-nose product placement, long-takes that draw attention to themselves at the expense of a given sequence, etc.), but more often than not, I’d argue a bigger problem in movie-making is the misguided attempt to force ostensible “substance” where it doesn’t belong. This may include everything from saccharine romances in genre-films to dialogue-driven humor in comedies to the photographs-of-people-talking that constitute most Oscar-bait, but my point is all the above have nothing to do with visual “style.”

The Katayanagi Twins’ electronica spirit animals battle Sex Bob-Omb’s rock ‘n roll spirit animal in an amazing musical-fight sequence at the climax of the film’s second act.

A great example of a film embracing style (striking editing techniques, memorable blocking, prolific special FX, dynamic camera movement, etc.) as its ultimate substance is Edgar Wright’s Scott Pilgrim vs. the World, adapted from the concurrent graphic novel series by Bryan Lee O’Malley. Scott Pilgrim vs. the World (henceforth, SPW) oozes such pulpy, colorful, playful charisma as a function of its comic book source that it made me appreciate just how “un-stylized” (re: non-cinematic) most comic-adaptations are. Continuing the trend of sidestream, non-superhero comic-adaptions (e.g. Hellboy [2004], Dredd [2012]) embracing their source material far better than their mainstream graphic novel counterparts (e.g. the DC Extended Universe [2013-present], the Marvel Cinematic Universe [2008-present]), SPW demonstrates how effective over-the-top comic fantasy can be as a filmmaking tool in the right hands. Those hands are Edgar Wright’s, in this case, as he waxes and weaves a masterful, gut-busting comedy that’s part comic wet-dream, hipster satire, musical, and kung fu videogame homage.

Though Wright is perhaps best known for his career-defining work with Simon Pegg and Nick Frost on the Cornetto Trilogy (2003, 2007, 2016), SPW is his greatest, most enduring feature. This is comparable to how John Carpenter’s most recognizable pop culture achievements are Halloween (1978) and Escape from New York (1981), but over time The Thing (1981) has solidified as his greatest work. SPW is both funnier than the entire Cornetto Trilogy without being as dependent on such striking cinematography or editing techniques, though both are still prevalent. Wright’s camera pans are smoother, his zooms more deliberate, his scene transitions more effective, and his quirky editing more refined. Though the movie is bursting with self-reflexive cinematography and colorful digital FX, everything is in service to the story’s progression, its characters’ development, and most of all, the film’s humor. Nothing is wasted in this $85 million action-comedy-musical special FX extravaganza.

Much of the time, it’s difficult to discern whether SPW is more action film or musical, given its simultaneous emphasis on both to generate unforgettable jokes. Kieran Culkin responds to a two-second (literally) rock performance by shouting, “It’s not a race, guys!“, but later Satya Bhabha summons Demon-hipster chicks to launch fireballs at lead Michael Cera, which precedes Cera competing in a funky bass guitar competition with superpowered (literally) vegan Brandon Routh, which is later outdone by Cera’s rock band, dubbed Sex Bob-Omb (I’m not kidding) creating a Tron (1982)-esque gorilla monster to fight equally Tron-esque twin dragons from a Japanese electronica duo, which is ultimately capped off by Cera dueling Jason Schwartzman in a cyber-katana fight that would make Kill Bill (2003-2004) proud. This is all in the same movie; it all works, too.

If I had to muster complaints about this picture, they would be in regards to some of the film’s incessant, cynical, sarcastic hipster nonsense. What I mean by that is everything annoying about snobbish liberal arts colleges, anime super-fans, videogame nerds, “indie” rock bands, and spoiled, upper middle-class Millennials is in this movie, personified by Michael Cera himself. Arguably Wright’s most impressive feat is turning all these cliches on their head, satirizing them effectively, while both subverting Cera’s unlikable personality and earning your sympathy for him at the same time. One could never believe a non-celebrity who looked and acted like Cera could compete for anybody’s ex-girlfriend, but the cinematic fantasy of it all, not to mention Cera’s titular character arc, sells it nonetheless. Aiding this cause is one of the greatest supporting casts of any comedy in the modern era, including Ellen Wong, Alison Pill, Anna Kendrick, Brie Larson, Aubrey Plaza, and Chris Evans. Yeah, that Chris Evans.

Though most of the movie follows Cera’s battles against Romana Flowers’ (Mary Elizabeth Winstead) “seven evil boyfriends exes,” here, Flowers takes charge against her fourth evil ex.

The ultimate argument for a great film like Scott Pilgrim vs. the World is that its style is its substance; Wright’s magnum opus is a better action film than most action flicks, Western or Eastern, is funnier than most comedies, animated or live-action, and is the best musical produced outside the Indian subcontinent in at least twenty years. The fact it can take someone like me, a person who is highly irritated by hipsters and indie rock bands, has little to no patience for Japanese animation or pop culture, and can’t stand Michael Cera as an actor, and make me love this film, is the greatest compliment I can muster. The movie is a multi-genre knockout.


SUMMARY & RECOMMENDATION: That Edgar Wright’s best film would have no contributions from the likes of Simon Pegg is surprising, but not as much as it starring the likes of Michael Cera. With the help of fantastical editing, psychedelic yet purposeful special FX, and a supporting cast with terrific chemistry, Scott Pilgrim vs. the World transforms into the ultimate celebration of white boy-hipster nerdiness. It’s hip, happening, and deserves to be blowing up your 4K TV right now.

However… nothing is more fantastical than portraying Cera as a “lady-killer,” however stylish his environment. He’s not even convincing as an underdog at the film’s outset.

—> HIGHLY RECOMMENDED, in case there was any doubt.

? Do you know how long it took to get all the evil exes’ contact information so I could form this stupid league? Like, two hours! TWO HOURS.

About The Celtic Predator

I love movies, music, video games, and big, scary creatures.


5 thoughts on “‘Scott Pilgrim vs. The World (2010): An Action-Musical Tour de Force

  1. Nice review. I have wanted to see this film but haven’t gotten around to it.

    Posted by Eric Bollinger | November 20, 2018, 10:25 pm


  1. Pingback: M. Night Shyamalan’s ‘Unbreakable’ (2000, 2016, 2019): Trilogy Review | Express Elevator to Hell - February 20, 2019

  2. Pingback: ‘Bleach’ (2018): Review | Express Elevator to Hell - March 17, 2019

  3. Pingback: How Long Should a Cinematic Narrative Be? | Express Elevator to Hell - March 4, 2020

  4. Pingback: ‘Everything, Everywhere, All at Once’ (2022): Too Much, Nowhere, None of the Time | Express Elevator to Hell - June 10, 2022

Am I spot on? Am I full of it? Let me know!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: